What do you think of the government’s plan to tackle indigenous child abuse by banning X rated pornography and alcohol?

Do you think it’s heavy handed and draconian – or good management of a serious problem?

Do you think these are good ideas that will help tackle the problem?

FOR:

The Prime Minster says we can’t afford to turn a blind eye to the abuse and neglect of children.

Mr Howard says the only way to help dysfunctional communities is by grabbing control of the communities, providing medical help for children, and stemming the flow of alcohol.

Mr Howard admits the measures are hardline, but says there’s nothing wrong with that, because it’s a crisis situation

Although the plan was initially criticised as being racist, Mr Howard now says all Australians who do not use welfare benefits for the good of their child - will have their payments quarantined

AGAINST:

Some have voiced reservations though….

Rex Wild QC, who we just heard from, says the government should have consulted indigenous people before taking action.

Clare Martin, Chief minister of the Northern Territory says she wrote to the Prime Minister a year ago, requesting action be taken on the issue, and is calling the government’s action now, nothing more than a ‘vote grab’ – leading up the federal election.

 There’s also concern about the sexual abuse checks on young children being inappropriate – to the point that they could be considered abuse in itself

Heavy handed and draconian? – or good management?